I’m trying to wrap my head around why Canadians are so upset about Air Canada CEO Michael Rousseau giving a speech mostly in English.
Maybe I’m missing something, but I always thought Quebec was the main French-speaking hub, with pockets of French sprinkled elsewhere. Not exactly shocking, then, that English might… show up in a speech.
This whole thing kind of reminds me of the uproar over the Super Bowl performance by Bad Bunny who, from what I heard because I didn’t watch it, performed in Spanish. And people were upset… because it wasn’t in English?
Meanwhile, here in Texas, I can’t even read a street sign without getting a mini language lesson. English, Spanish, Asian, and Indigenous languages can sometimes appear all on the same pole. And nobody faints. We just keep driving.
That’s kind of what happens when you live in the real world today. It’s big, it’s mixed, and it doesn’t come with subtitles.
If we want smart, talented people from all over the globe to come here, work here, and contribute (wherever your here might be), we might have to loosen our grip on the idea that everything should feel familiar all the time. Comfort is nice—but growth usually isn’t.
Now, does that mean I personally embrace every cultural difference with open arms? Oh, absolutely not. I’ve got my limits (Burkas, for instance). But there’s a difference between “that’s not for me” and “that shouldn’t exist.”
At the end of the day, maybe the goal isn’t to make everything sound like us but to stop being so surprised when it doesn’t.
And if a little French or Spanish in the mix is the worst thing we’re dealing with… I’d say we’re doing just fine.
More later ... and comment if you understand the bruhaha.
Hello Dear Barbara,
ReplyDeleteCanada is an officially bilingual country. This means that English AND French have equality of status and equal rights and privileges as to their use in ALL institutions.
The Official Languages Act (1969) established English and French as the two official languages of the federal government, ensuring federal services are provided in both languages.
It has nothing to do with comfort or growth.
Hope that clears things up.
Air Canada is a federal Crown Corporation and is therefore bound by the Official Languages Act to provide service in both French and English. All its employees must be bilingual. When hired years ago, the unilingual English CEO promised to learn French. He made no effort to do so. In his nationally broadcast speech concerning the recent deaths of two Air Canada pilots in the USA, he used only two French words -- "Bonjour" at the beginning and "Merci" at the end. The minimum standard for a bilingual speech is to repeat everything in both English and French, something he was obviously incapable of doing. Not only was he in breach of the Official Languages Act, his essentially English-only speech was seen as a personal slap in the face to the deceased Quebec pilot and his family. In my opinion, he should have been fired and not simply allowed to retire in a few months. Air Canada better make sure its next CEO is truly bilingual.
ReplyDeleteAgreed.
DeleteOk. I didn't know about the Official Languages Act. I read up on it a little and now it makes a little more sense.
DeleteI knew none of the above but I knew that Air Canada was headquartered in Montreal so I figured that was why they wanted French. It is funny to me that it is mandated. But if he said he'd learn and didn't well then...we got an issue. I took French in high school. I was in Montreal and tried to speak. I apologized and the person, waved me off and walked away muttering probably horrible things. I tired and then we decided to leave Montreal and go back to Ontario. We were treated so badly because they didn't like our poor French. Not sure I blame them but honestly it was just rude to me. But when visiting one must respect their ways and if I can't leave. I never wish to offend.
ReplyDeleteThe clincher was they were speaking English until we got closer to them then they refused. Warm and welcoming.
ReplyDeleteI'm so sorry that was your experience, Peggy. We ARE a warm and welcoming bunch, Canadians, loved and respected globally actually.
DeleteMaybe you got someone on a bad day ♥
Great post! I love what you're saying about there being a difference between “that’s not for me” and “that shouldn’t exist.” I also love your paragraph about road signs. I also agree with you about Burka's. People with their faces covered are so creepy and not something we're used to seeing here.
ReplyDelete